Community recommendations
Pizza · Huntington Beach · Algonquin
Last mentioned Feb 2026
5 source comments from 5 contributors across 5 threads. Community score 6, based on shared upvotes and repeat contributors.
Recommendations describe the experience when the comment was posted. Check current details before visiting.
u/RockStarx1 · Feb 2026
Slice of New York (theres one on both sides of you in Seal Beach and Huntington Beach) IMO its as good as you'll get in the area as far as NY style goes. If you want strictly "in" sunset, Stoneys is pretty good and sells by the slice.Read the full comment on Reddit →
u/Caaw_Caaw · Jun 2023
I'm a fan of A Slice of NY, on Algonquin & WarnerRead the full comment on Reddit →
u/49Princess_51Rebel · May 2023
A Slice of New York Pizza on Algonquin (in the shopping center) has gluten-free pizza that is pretty decent. You can even get it by the slice which never happens. Their chicken wings are also gluten free. And they even have gluten-free penne but I haven't tried that yet so I can't vouch for it.Read the full comment on Reddit →
u/foeplay44 · Feb 2024
RIIP on Magnolia. Slice of Pizza, delicious IPA, and thumbing through my cell phone is the kind of peace I enjoy.Read the full comment on Reddit →
u/manderson_ · Apr 2017
Coming from NY, I was pretty underwhelmed by the pizza options in HB. With that said, I would recommend A Slice of New York Pizza http://www.thebestsliceofnewyork.com/ . It has been a pretty solid choice for me when the craving hits.Read the full comment on Reddit →
Excerpts are attributed to their original Reddit sources. About the collection and removal requests.